With the fairly recent BBC survey showing that 1 in 4 people today believe that Capitalism is failing and that Socialism is a good alternative, I believe all of us need to engage in this conversation...with the facts.
So, here are some 'talking points' on the differences:
Socialism & Communism in a Nutshell
Socialism, the cousin of Communism, refers to an economic system, which seeks to control the market, essentially for "the redistribution of wealth." Karl Marx, father of Marxism, the foundation of socialism and communism, said, "From each, according to his ability; to each, according to his need.” Some confuse this view with Christian compassion, however, in reality Socialism is really 'Communism-lite."
Communism refers to both an economic and a political system, which seeks to manage the economy and the society by controlling the distribution of property and wealth, in order to "achieve both classlessness and statelessness."
Socialism seeks to manage the economy through "deliberate and collective social control." Communism on the other hand, seeks to manage both the economy and the society by controlling the working person, who is paid "according to their abilities and needs." In other words, the government determines each citizen's abilities and needs. Their slogan is, "Workers of the world unite!" a phrase we see painted on banners and signs in protests across America, more and more.
Communism does not value private property. Karl Marx, said: "You reproach us with planning to do away with your property. Precisely; that is just what we propose." And in the Communist Manifesto we find: "Point 1: Abolition of property in land and application of all rents of land to public
purposes." Marx bottom-lined it with, “The theory of Communism may be summed up in one sentence: Abolish all private property."
Both socialism and communism are anti-Capitalism.
In their Communist Manifesto Karl Marx and Fredrich Engels outlined the goals of Marxism, which is a vision of "a future society free from class antagonism, which will purportedly be brought about by the establishment of communism and the demise of oppressive capitalism." Thus, the end goal of Marxism is a future one-world communist, capitalistic-free, utopian state.
Capitalism is an economic system based on the free exchange of goods and services, without fraud, theft and breech of contract; it is a free market economy.
Karl Marx also said, “Democracy is the road to socialism.” That's why it's important for all of us to understand the difference between a democracy and a republic, which our kids are not being taught well in school. America is a Republic, ie "...and to the Republic, for which it stands...one nation under God..."
Which brings me to one last thing on Marx...his idea about God. He said much on the subject including, "Religion is the impotence of the human mind to deal with occurrences it cannot understand” "Religion is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless world, and the soul of soulless conditions. It is the opium of the people." And for our topic, probably most important, "My object in life is to dethrone God and destroy capitalism."
Believe it or not, the historical goal of 'social justice' comes out of the Marxist worldview. That's not to say churches that are using the phrase today for social action are following Marx, but then again, some are. A quick research on the subject will reveal the Marxist 'liberation theology' roots. Frankly, this is why we call our radio show "Changing Worldviews," because worldviews change with each generation, and often those worldviews are just old views repackaged. History does repeat itself. But, that's a subject for another time.
Back to the BBC survery -- this is not the first time a country rethinks it's economic policies when dealing with a huge financial crisis. It is also not the first time that Marxist/Socialist advocates are extolling their view and criticizing Capitalism, using the argument of -- "FAIRNESS." But, is Marxism fair? Let me answer with a question: Is life fair?
If you are interested in more on this subject, I recommend my interview with Dr. Jay Richards of the Discovery Institute, on his book, "Money, Greed & God," where he gets into the issue of Christian compassion vs. government redistribution. You can listen to it online on our website, just look for "MONEYTalk: Right vs. Left on Socialism & Capitalism" dated Nov. 7, 2011 in our broadcast archives at www.changingworldviews.com.
Other Commentaries by Sharon Hughes
New Year Resolutions & Money
Where Is The Hope?
Confessions Of A Reluctant Prepper
Leave A Lasting Legacy
Worldviews Do Matter
Where Are The Entertainment Police?
Let's Talk Money
Stupor Tuesday & March Madness
Disappointment After Planned Parenthood Was Been Exposed
Take Your Place In The Public Square, Please!
The 'Silent Shame' Many Women Face
Jews Speak Up For Christmas!
Remembering The John Kerry Of A Few Years Back
Time To Rise Up & Take A Stand!
The "Evolving" Gay Marriage Debate
Could You Have Passed The 8th Grade In 1895?
Al Gore Promoter Of Doomsday Cult?
What Does It Mean To Love Your Country?
Tears Of A Grateful Nation
The Unthinkable Is Never A Solution
Unbelievable Population Control Quotes By The 'Elite'
Climategate & Copenhagen
What's In The Healthcare Bill?
Envision All Women Free!
Money Management Not Madness!
How To Survive The Insanity
Bill Maher Still Ranting On Religion And Politics
A Thanksgiving Legacy
Make Veterans Day Memorable
Not Your Father's Democrat
Al Gore Evoking The Wrath Of God To Validate His Claims
Sf Mayor Ecstatic Over Gay Marriage
Obama's "Typical White Person" Ought Oh!
Barack Obama's Very Controversial Pastor
What's With All The Candidate 'Faith Talk'?
Gays Mock Jesus & The Last Supper
Throw Away Babies
Al Gore Lobbying For The Nobel Peace Prize
Why Roe Vs. Wade Is Losing Ground
Responses To ‘Ahmadinejad’S Letter’
Ahmadinejad’S Letter To America
Raising Pagan Children, Scary
'Five Pillars Of Islam’ Vs. The Pope In Schools
True Colors Of Bigotry Busting Out All Over The Place!
War In Iraq Who Is Telling The Truth?
Anti Semitism On The Rise In Europe. Scary!
Preschool For All Initiative, What 'Meathead's' Not Telling You
Terrorism & Our Canadian Border
Teachers Debate Teaching Creationism
Left Wing Gives Ammo To Conservatives
Carter's At It Again
Gay Marriage Where Do Teachers Stand?
A Hamas Win Bad For Israel
Jews Speak Up For Christmas
New York Times Accepts The Unacceptable
Court Gone Mad! 9th Circuit Court Rules Against Parents
Red Alert On Codepink!
Media Fails To Report On Anti War Group's 'Letter From God'
What The Blinkity Blink Is Going On With The Liberal Msm?
Anti Military, Recruitment & Our Youth
Katrina Blows Sheehan, Gay Marriage Off The Screen
Real Racism, Katrina And More...
Yesterday Japan's Surrender. Today Jews Being Forced To...
Ny Times Only Tells Half The Story On Sheehan's Statements
Adult Vs. Embryonic Stem Cell Researh
Is This The End Of The Eu?
A New Face For Gay Pride
Absentee Dads A National Crisis?
The Effects Of Evolution's Racist Roots On Students
From Sci Fi To Sci Fact
To Spit Or Not To Spit, On Jane Fonda That Is The Question
Brave New World Re Visited?
These Are The Times (And Tough Questions) That Try Men's Souls
A Look Back
The Unanswered Questions Of Stem Cell Research
Gore Criticizes Bush's Faith
Compulsory Mental Health Screening Is Coming
Truth, Truth, Where Art Thou?
Stem Cell Wars & The Presidency
Traditional Marriage Wins In California
America Looks At The Wives
The John John Ticket Richest In History
Cloning Cats Schwarzenegger's 'Sixth Day' Has Arrived
'Memorial Day A Time To Remember
'Day Of Silence' Just A Foot In The Door
Anti American Professors
Crooked And Straight Cops
When Idols Fall
The Battle Over The "C" Word
The Pc (Political Correctness) Police
ON THE AIR
SUNDAYS 3-5:00pm PST
Tune in to KMYC 1410AM
LISTEN LIVE ONLINE HERE
SUNDAYS 10am-12Noon MTN
Tune in to KYAH 540AM
LISTEN LIVE ONLINE HERE
SATURDAYS & SUNDAYS 6-8:00am & 10am-Noon EST
SUNDAYS 3-5:00pm PST
MONDAY, WEDNESDAY, FRIDAY & SATURDAY
LISTEN HERE 24/7
News in Quotes
"The United States is designating North Korea as a state sponsor of terrorism,” “Should have happened a long time ago." -Pres. Trump
You Gotta Be Kidding! Quote
“The fact of the matter is without communication, we have no way of knowing of you are sentient or not,” the unidentified student said. “It’s no different than this tree. It’s alive, but is it sentient? I don’t know. I cannot communicate with it.” -Student At Tennessee University
Read along with us!
Questions: Email email@example.com
"I so appreciate all you do to help keep us informed." -Kris Seidler
"Truth Woman! Truth has fallen in the streets; we need the Belt more than ever!!" -Steve Simpson
"My reception is not very good so I have my ear plastered against the radio trying to catch every word!" -Sara Haskins